Perfect Homemade Whipped Potatoes
Hello friends! Here in the US, we are officially on the “Thanksgiving countdown”. Whether your Thanksgiving table is set for one or twenty, there are always yummy side dishes that feel entirely mandatory. (Smile) Someone around the table will always say, “We could make a whole meal out of just the sides,” and honestly, it would be simply amazing!
Calling all carb lovers, today I am sharing one of my absolute favorite side dishes. Say hello to whipped potatoes, baby! Yes, even with dietary restrictions, I can still enjoy them. (smile)
This recipe is so easy, you’ll love its sweet simplicity.

My hubby makes our whipped potatoes, and they are perfect every time! He uses Yukon Gold potatoes right from our garden, lactose-free milk, margarine, and a trusty hand mixer. He whips them until they are smooth in texture and able to hold a peak that stands all on its own. A little salt and pepper can be added right at the table.

When you’re making these yummy potatoes, these proportions work well for us:
For Yukon Golds: You’ll need 2 per person if they are 4 inches or larger, or 3 per person if they are 3½ to 4 inches. Try not to go smaller than 3½ inches if possible.
For Russets: You’ll need about 1 large potato (5 to 6 inches in length) per person.
If your family loves having leftovers like we do, simply double the proportions per person!
What You’ll Need
- Yukon Gold or Russet potatoes
- A large stockpot
- A hand mixer (or stand mixer)
- A colander
- A potato peeler
- A cutting board and sharp knife
- A large slotted spoon
- Salt and Pepper (optional)
Make sure you have a pot big enough for all of your potatoes to fit without any spilling over. Fill it about three-quarters of the way with water and add a pinch of salt.
While the water is coming up to a boil, clean, peel, and cut your potatoes into about 1½-inch cubes. When the water reaches a rapid boil, use your slotted spoon to gently lower the potatoes into the water a few at a time to prevent any splashing.
Boil them until they are fork-tender (about 10 minutes). Carefully drain the potatoes using your colander, and then pop them right back into the warm pot.
Add a teaspoon of margarine (or butter) per person, along with approximately ¼ cup of milk per person. Always add the margarine first and give the potatoes a little smash. Next, add your milk gradually, whip them on medium speed. (NOTE– you might not need all of the milk!) until they are smooth in texture and can hold a firm peak that stands on its own. Just be careful not to over-whip them; they need to have enough body to hold a spoonful of gravy! (Smile)
A Fix It Tip: If you happen to whip them a little too much or add slightly too much milk, don’t worry, I have a quick fix! Sprinkle in a tiny bit of instant potato flakes to thicken them. Or you can “cook it off” by keeping the potatoes in the pot, moving them back to the stove over low heat, and stirring gently until they reach just the right consistency.
*Katie’s Tid Bits- Consider adding some fresh herbs or finely chopped green onions if you aren’t planning on serving them with gravy.
I hope you will enjoy every single bite. I’ll see you tomorrow for the TFT (Thursday Favorite Things) blog hop.
download currently unavailable
Hugs!
HAVE YOU ENTERED THE NEW GIVEAWAY YET?